Dialogue is listening and exchanging ideas in search of better
understanding, and perhaps new solutions.
Dialogue is not debate, argumentation or refutation; it does not seek
to critique the others, to prove anyone wrong, or to "win."
|
When Dialoguing You Seek To … |
When Debating You Try To… |
|
·
Examine your assumptions |
· Prove that your assumptions are right |
|
·
Question your beliefs |
·
Critique their beliefs |
|
·
Remain open to new ideas |
·
Close your mind to new ideas |
|
·
Temporarily suspend your beliefs |
·
Become more and more sure of your beliefs |
|
·
Expand and possibly change someone’s point of view |
·
Prove to others and
to yourself that you are right |
|
·
Listen carefully to the other side in order to
understand |
·
Listen just to find weaknesses in the other side’s
arguments |
|
·
Look for areas of agreement |
·
Look for differences |
|
·
Find the strengths in the other side’s positions |
·
Find the weaknesses in the other side’s positions |
|
·
Avoid offending or alienating the other side |
·
Belittle the other side to prove them wrong |
|
·
Work with the "other side" to come to a new
understanding |
·
Work against the other side to prove them wrong |
|
·
Put all good ideas together to come up with a workable
solution |
·
Convince them that your answer is the only answer |
|
·
Find common ground |
·
Win |
|
·
Keep the discussion going |
·
End the discussion by proving that you’re right |