Home
Prior Meetings
Our Next Meeting
Meet Some of Our Members
How We Work
Dialogue vs Debate
Compassionate Listening
Presentation Guidelines

Some Differences Between Dialogue and Debate

Dialogue is listening and exchanging ideas in search of better understanding, and perhaps new solutions.

Dialogue is not debate, argumentation or refutation; it does not seek to critique the others, to prove anyone wrong, or to "win."

Here are some of the key differences between dialogue and debate. 

When Dialoguing You Seek To …

When Debating You Try To…

·  Examine your assumptions

·  Prove that your assumptions are right

·  Question your beliefs

·  Critique their beliefs

·  Remain open to new ideas

·  Close your mind to new ideas

·  Temporarily suspend your beliefs

·  Become more and more sure of your beliefs

·  Expand and possibly change someone’s point of view

·   Prove to others and to yourself that you are right

·  Listen carefully to the other side in order to understand

·  Listen just to find weaknesses in the other side’s arguments

·  Look for areas of agreement

·  Look for differences

·  Find the strengths in the other side’s positions

·  Find the weaknesses in the other side’s positions

·  Avoid offending or alienating the other side

·  Belittle the other side to prove them wrong

·  Work with the "other side" to come to a new understanding

·  Work against the other side to prove them wrong

·  Put all good ideas together to come up with a workable solution

·  Convince them that your answer is the only answer

·  Find common ground

·  Win

·  Keep the discussion going

·  End the discussion by proving that you’re right


Dialogue is an exchange of ideas and experiences.

Dialogue can bring together seemingly
incompatible peoples and ideas.

Dialogue can produce new understandings
and relationships you would not have thought possible.
 

 


The Muslim-Jewish Dialogue Group
 of Los Angeles

 

Last updated:

Jewish-Muslim Dialogue Group of Los Angeles © 2006 - 2008